By Oscar Savage, Graduate Planner, Baseline Group Marlborough | Mar 21, 2023
Plantation forestry have been promoted as a cure for many of our societal ills, with benefits towards alleviating the climate crisis, generation of income from marginal land, and providing economic benefits via widespread employment. However, recent extreme weather events have highlighted some of the flaws of plantation forestry. This has forced central governments to reconsider if widespread plantation forestry a land use deserving of our continued active support. Or is it time to manage the industry differently seeking better environmental outcomes for all?
Landowners have been able to obtain financial support from the government to plant both native and exotic forests through the One Billion Trees Fund, which allocated $176 million of funding to support the establishment of forests. The project sought to plant more natives than exotics; however, the result is a vast majority of the funded tree plantings are exotic pine forests. The forestry industry also has the benefit of streamlined regulatory support under the National Environmental Standards for Plantation forestry (NES-PF). This document provides national level management for key forestry activities instead of regional and district plans on a region-by-region basis. The NES-PF provides a consistent regulatory environment which overrides any local provisions and allows foresters to carry out activities that would require specific consideration through a resource consent for operators outside of the forestry industry.
Plantation Forestry can provide significant benefits compared to other land uses. Exotic forestry sequesters significantly more carbon than native forests, and can provide more income than low intensity agricultural grazing. The conversion of as little as 5% of New Zealand’s dry stock farms is theorised to be capable of generation $760 million in profit per year for the rural economy.
Forestry’s benefits can come at a cost, and recent extreme weather events have brought this to the public eye again. Storms in 2018 resulted in $1.3 million in fines being levied against Forestry companies by Gisborne District Council for damage caused by forest effects. Recent storms in 2023 including Cyclone Gabrielle have shown the how forestry’s uncleared slash continues to exacerbate flooding effects, and forests caught in their post-harvest window of vulnerability can send astounding quantities of silt downstream from erosion prone sites, burying productive land downstream.
Given the often-prominent position of forestry in the headwaters of catchments, it is now being debated by some as to whether this is truly a safe and sustainable land use, or if this industry needs to be managed with more local input. Is the national management of forestry under the NES-PF suitable given the repeated damage from natural hazards to communities in Tairāwhiti made worse by forestry harvesting methods? Ministerial enquiries due at the end of April may spark changes in the forestry industry in light of the damage seen.
Articles you might be interested in
- Balancing Common Sense and Legal Process under the RMA: Protecting Communities and the Environment
- Is the RMA really the problem?
- Hazardous activities, land contamination and resource consent applications
- The Role of Planning in the Climate Change - Discussion for Agriculture
- Our History - How We All Play a Part in its Protection
- Housing Intensification – Not for Everyone Says CCC
- A recent Baseline Group project was recognised at the 2022 Canterbury Architecture Awards
- Time's up on the RMA
- Councils are Increasing Residential Density, but why, who does it benefit?
- Rural Allotment Sizes set to Double
- Game changers for housing under the RMA
- State highways, noise and reverse sensitivity: what’s the buzz?
- How might Development Contributions affect you?
- Highly Productive Soils – Big Picture Thinking vs Private Landowners Needs
- Cross lease titles - an overview
- Who Shapes our Planning Rules?
- Commercial Activity in a Rural Zone – What’s the Harm?
- Crunch Time For New Freshwater Legislation
- Why we have complicated septic tank disposal rules
- Buildings under exemptions may still need resource consent
- Changes to Resource Management Planning Signalled in Proposed Legislation
- How lizards might affect your new development
- The dream of subdividing your land
- Tiny Home Revolution May Not Save Costs
- Managing Cultural Heritage Sites
- Minimum car parking requirements to be chopped
- A Practical Guide for District Plan Reviews
- Make Your Additional Land Profitable Under the Selwyn Proposed Plan
- Planning land use to be resilient to natural hazards
- Outstanding Natural Features and Landscapes - effect on farming
- What does a professional planner do?
- Housing Growth continues in Selwyn with Legislative Support
- Highly Productive Soils – Big Picture Thinking vs Private Landowners Needs
- Indigenous Biodiversity: what does it mean for a farmer?
- Minimum Car Parking Requirements to be Chopped
- Proposed Selwyn District Plan Update
- Change isn't coming, it's here!
- Selwyn District Council Changes Urban Allotment Sizes
- Is it a Wetland or Not?
- Good District Plan provisions save time and money
- Rural allotment sizes set to double in West Selwyn
- Negotiating with Neighbours Under the RMA
- The impact of consent notices when purchasing land
- Boundary disputes – What are they and how can you resolve them?
- Fundamental Culture Shift in New Zealand Planning Legislation.
- Spotlight on District Plan Provisions
- But that’s the way we have always done it!
- Planning Rules can Affect Property Value
- The importance of knowing your boundaries
- Burning crop stubble on your property?
- Planning Permissions – Resource Consent or Plan Change?
- Have your say on Development Projects
- Proposed Selwyn District Plan - What next?
- Risks to farmland in the planning framework
- Wild Weather and Resource Consent Requirements
- RMA changes are coming, are you ready?
- What to do when you inherit land
- Who Pays for Infrastructure in Greenfield Land Development?
- District Plan in Selwyn – How will it Affect You?